Review: The Mysteries of Gore Vidal

There are many great mystery writers that we’ve all probably read. Agatha Christie and Arthur Conan Doyle come to mind. There are also authors from other genres who also wrote great mysteries. Among them are JK Rowling, Nora Roberts, and Gore Vidal. Wait…Gore Vidal?

Yes, Gore Vidal. Back in the early 1950s, he had been blacklisted and could not get anything published. Publisher Victor Weybright suggested he write a murder mystery and he’d publish it. (BTW, Gore Vidal was not his legal name either.) Over lunch, Weybright suggested he use Edgar after mystery writer Edgar Wallace. After lunch the pair went to a party that afternoon for a Mr. and Mrs. Box. It didn’t take long for Vidal to come up with the name Edgar Box.

From 1952-1954, Edgar Box wrote three mystery novels, all are led by amateur sleuth and public relations specialist Peter Sargeant. The novels are frequently combined into a single tome. I read them under the combined name “Boxed In”.

In “Death in the Fifth Position”, Sargeant is hired to publicize a ballet company. When the lead dancer is killed during a performance and lands in the fifth postion, he gets pulled into solving the murder.

My favorite of the three is “Death Like it Hot.” A terrific name for a mystery. In this story, Sargeant is hired to do a big PR splash for an ambitious Senator. But he ends up dead on the night before he’s to announce is run for President.

The last story is “Death Before Bedtime.” I like the love interest in this story the best. Here, Sargeant spends a week at the home of a Long Island socialite where he is hired to get the word out for a big party. But when one of the house guests, the wife of a famous painter, ends up dead, he again jumps into action to solve the murder.

All three stories are a delight. Just as you think you know who the killer is, Box twists things in a way that has you guessing again. You really don’t know until the very end. I was left wishing he’d written more mysteries. If you’re looking for light-hearted, well written stories, you can’t go wrong here. Open the Box and give them a read.

Leave a Reply